Why this role stands out
This role offers a fantastic opportunity to develop your investigative and analytical skills by resolving diverse claims within a reputable retail environment. You'll thrive here if you possess strong critical thinking and a knack for uncovering facts, contributing to sound outcomes and a supportive team. Apply today to leverage your experience in a role with competitive hourly pay and significant impact.
Quick overview
Job description
We’re looking for a detail-oriented Claims Investigator to support the fair, accurate, and timely resolution of general liability, property damage, and Injury claims across our convenience store and fuel station locations.
In this role, you’ll conduct fact-based investigations, gather evidence, interview involved parties, and provide clear, well-documented findings that support claim decisions. This position partners closely with the Claims Manager and collaborates with internal teams, insurance carriers, third-party administrators, and legal partners.
If you have a background in investigations and enjoy uncovering facts, assessing risk, and supporting sound outcomes, then this may just be the role for you!
What You’ll Do
- Investigate general liability incidents such as slip/trip and falls or customer injuries
- Investigate property damage claims involving customers or third-party vendors
- Investigate carwash incidents involving customer vehicle damage
- Collect evidence, review documentation, conduct interviews, and analyze surveillance footage
- Evaluate facts to assess liability, identify root cause, and flag potential fraud or negligence
- Prepare clear, professional investigative reports for claim evaluation and litigation support
- Maintain accurate and timely documentation in the claims management system
- Communicate findings, concerns, and red flags to the General Liability Claims Manager
- Coordinate with insurance carriers, TPAs, legal counsel, and store-level teams
- Assist with customer outreach or follow-up as needed
What You Bring
- 2+ years of investigative experience in law enforcement, private investigation, insurance claims, loss prevention, or risk management
- Strong analytical and critical-thinking skills with the ability to assess liability objectively
- Professional and confident communication style when interacting with claimants, store teams, and legal partners
- Excellent written and verbal communication skills
- Proficiency in Microsoft Word, Excel, and Outlook
- Ability to remain calm and professional in sensitive or high-stress situations
- Experience reviewing surveillance footage and working with DVR systems is a plus
- Collaborative mindset with a strong track record of working effectively across teams
- Bachelor’s degree preferred, or an equivalent combination of education and experience
Pay for this position is $25-$30 an hour DOE
- Medical, Dental, Vision and Life Insurance
- 401K Plan
- Paid Time Off
Haystack's AI agent can fill in and submit this application for you. How AI auto apply works
Similar jobs
- CO
Lease Audit Review / Silver StarRecently posted Auto Apply
City of New York · New York City, NY · On-site · Posted 14 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
Financial AnalysisProject ManagementFinanceSalary not listed - AT

Assurance SeniorRecently posted Auto Apply
ATKG · San Antonio · Hybrid · Posted 14 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
AuditingCPAGAAPSalary not listed - AB

Lead Quality Dossier Program Auditor - Hybrid, ChicagoRecently posted Auto Apply
AbbVie · North Chicago, IL · On-site · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
Technology$109.5k - $208.5k/yr - PC
Lead Medical Coder and Auditor [PR0001D] Auto Apply
ProSidian Consulting, LLC · Fort Stewart, GA · On-site 🇺🇸
Microsoft ExcelMicrosoft OfficeMicrosoft Word+5HealthcareSalary not listed - BG
Quality Auditor (2nd Shift)Recently posted Auto Apply
Bosch Group · West Memphis, AR · On-site · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
Microsoft ExcelRoboticsTechnology$20 - $24/hr - JL
FSQ Auditor - 2nd ShiftRecently posted Auto Apply
Jack Link's Protein Snacks · New Glarus, WI · On-site · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
Microsoft ExcelMicrosoft WordMicrosoft PowerPointManufacturing$17 - $25/hr - MO
PM Reception Agent / Overnight Night Auditor (with FLSD)Recently posted Auto Apply
Motel One · New York, NY · On-site · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
AdministrativeSalary not listed - FI

Senior Sales Enablement Manager, Corporate Internal AuditRecently posted Auto Apply
Fieldguide · Remote (USA) · Remote · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
OnboardingArticulateCPA+5SalesSalary not listed - CA
Audit SupervisorRecently posted Auto Apply
Current Advisors · Somerset · Hybrid · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
AuditingCPACompliance+4$110k - $125k/yr - GL

IT Audit SpecialistRecently posted Auto Apply
Glsllc · Greenville · Hybrid · Posted 13 Nov 2026 🇺🇸
WorkdayContinuous ImprovementFMLA+5Salary not listed - PC
Audit Coordination Specialist [DOE0072071] Auto Apply
ProSidian Consulting, LLC · Richland, WA · On-site 🇺🇸
Microsoft ExcelMicrosoft OfficeMicrosoft PowerPoint+2Operations & Project ManagementSalary not listed - PC
Audit Coordination Specialist [DOE0042041] Auto Apply
ProSidian Consulting, LLC · Richland, WA · On-site 🇺🇸
Microsoft ExcelMicrosoft OfficeMicrosoft PowerPoint+1Operations & Project ManagementSalary not listed