Quick overview
Job description
Supplement Renewal Specialist
$3,000/month base + $50 per enrollment + [commission on ancillary sales] · [Office] · Current team members only
This is a renewal role. Every call goes to an existing Century client.
A Medicare Supplement (also called Medigap) is a plan that pays costs Original Medicare doesn’t, like deductibles and coinsurance. Supplement premiums go up over time.
Many states have a birthday rule: a state law that lets someone switch to a supplement plan with the same or fewer benefits around their birthday, with no health questions. Every state sets its own window. Every year, as a supplement client’s birthday window opens, you call them for their renewal review: what they’re paying now, and whether a plan with the same benefits would lower their monthly premium.
No cold calls and no leads. Every person on your list is already our client, and your job is to keep them with us by making sure they aren’t overpaying.
On top of renewals, a successful rep cross-sells ancillary products: extra coverage a supplement doesn’t include, like [dental, vision, hearing, hospital indemnity, short term home health care and home health care]. You’re already on the phone with a client who trusts us. Find the gap, and fill it.
The deal
You get: $3,000/month base plus $50 for every enrollment, plus [commission] on every ancillary product you sell. Example: 30 enrollments in a month is $1,500 on top of your base, before any ancillary sales.
It costs: precision. One missed step and a client ends up paying for two policies, or holding none.
The rule that matters most
The old policy is never canceled until the new policy is approved and in force.
Cancel too early and the client can be left with no coverage. Cancel too late and they pay two premiums. Both are on you. The follow-up is the job, not an afterthought to it.
The work
Work the renewal list. Call our existing supplement clients as their state’s window opens. Know each state’s birthday and GI rules.
Run the comparison. Current premium against plans with the same or fewer benefits for example changing from F,G, or N. Switch them only when it actually saves money and they understand exactly what changes.
Enroll it clean. Application, the replacement notice (the required form when one supplement replaces another), recorded line, every time.
Cross-sell what fits. On every renewal call, ask about the gaps a supplement leaves, like teeth, eyes, hearing, or help at home after a hospital stay.
Follow it through. Confirm the new policy is approved. Then cancel the old one. Then confirm with the client that the old policy is gone and the new one is billing correctly.
Log everything, the same day.
You’re measured on
Enrollments · ancillary sales per renewal call · Stick rate
Who we want
Detail-oriented. You finish the paperwork today, not tomorrow. Open tasks bother you.
Clear on the phone. You can explain a premium comparison to a 75-year-old in two sentences.
Curious on the phone. You ask the second question. You hear “my teeth have been bothering me” and know what to do with it.
Trusted with our clients. You treat a client’s coverage like it’s your mother’s.
Requirements: licensed and appointed [6]+ months at Century. No compliance escalations in [6] months. Your manager’s sign-off.
Not for you if you love the close but hate the follow-up, or you let tasks sit.
Haystack's AI agent can fill in and submit this application for you. How AI auto apply works
